-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1
Am 14.05.2015 um 14:03 schrieb Wallis,Richard:
> Going back to the original question - although bf:title was used as an
> example, it is a pattern that is repeated for many properties across the vocab
ulary.
>
> Many would also want to say:
>
> <http://bibframe.example.com/workX> bf:creator “William Shakespeare” .
maybe I'm already blinded by too much RDF exposure, but wouldn't evoce some
"creator" attribute the gist of an entity in ~many~? And therefore they would
not have trouble understanding a more convoluted phrase like "workX is by
the creator who goes by the name "William Shakespeare"?
This of course does not decide the original question, since it allows either
a "more aggregated" property to assert
<http://bibframe.example.com/workX> bf:creatorName “William Shakespeare”
or the exact mapping of the indirection already contained in the natural
language expressoin (the entity known as ...) by insertion of an anonymous
node:
<http://bibframe.example.com/workX> bf:creator [ rdfs:label “William
Shakespeare” ].
For me string valued statements like
<http://bibframe.example.com/workX> xy:creator “William Shakespeare”
negate the possibility of the object being an entity and therefore make
sense only within an restricted model or context xy which a priory has
agreed upon not ever needing entities as values for the "creator" predicate.
[So actually this (creators "are" strings) reflects the AACR2 mindset, where
the "label" as a string is in 1:1 correspondence to a real world object
and linking the data to something outside the bib record would just increase
the complexity without gaining anything]
viele Gruesse
Thomas Berger
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1
Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - http://www.enigmail.net/
iJwEAQECAAYFAlVUpV8ACgkQYhMlmJ6W47Pi1QP+Iy4bU3K7SgAg55ns2ahKvyPK
rmFg9m9cMq841i5SfeNJL2yB+CMUXD7zOVk63kDH2ULr/lvFNnlqNmVkwLIPN/Oh
13cAX26V8CvLR+92q1pcBHdA9jc3lO42EKW8UCaWxhATKxApxpXzgKC3+J65mgpU
3cDzgmWmfgwF/sH93z8=
=aK1O
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
|