Have you done anything to tune the acoustics of the space? Any such work may well dictate the characteristics of the monitors that would serve you best. Monitors and acoustics are both integral components of the listening environment. The best monitors in the world can't overcome substandard acoustics. FWIW, I haven't used wither of the two you mention though I know different engineers that have used each without major complaints. In my studio I use Quested VS2108's and at work we use Genelec S30d's and I like them both but again, each in a space tuned and designed knowing what monitors would be used.
On Jun 6, 2012, at 2:57 PM, Grant, Tyra wrote:
> We're evaluating studio monitors for our small (14'x14') audio room---with workstation close-to being against a wall. We prefer to spend $1,500, more or less.
> We're focusing on 1) Mackie HR624 MkIIs and 2) Genelec 8030As
> Unfortunately, we have no way to test-run either of these---or any others for that matter.
> We'd really appreciate hearing comments or suggestions relating to experience with these models or any other monitors that might be worth our consideration.
> I hope this request isn't out-of-line.
> Tyra Grant
> Digital and electronic media preservation officer
> University of Kansas Libraries
> [log in to unmask]<mailto:[log in to unmask]>