I use NAS over ethnernet only. I don't have any current machines that
I would recommend. I know about the speed issue transferring files
with my old NAS.
I just want to say you should not opt for USB based on connection
speed alone. Gigabit ethernet seems widely available these days.
According to wikipedia USB 2.0 has effectively 280MB/s, USB 3.0
perhaps 3.2 Gbit/s. Considering that my old NASs run at ~55% of
network speek, a Gigabit NAS on a Gigabit network should have 600MB/s
or more (just guessing here). Seems enough as long as you connect via
cable. Wireless definitely doesn't work. Perhaps use a dedicated
network for NAS only.
I prefer standalone NAS devices which do not depend on my PC running.
Seems more future proof, e.g. if I buy another PC, laptop etc. and
want to access disk space from anywhere in network. After all, NAS
stands for Network attached storage.
Just my 2 cents.
On Tue, Apr 16, 2013 at 8:10 AM, Tom Fine <[log in to unmask]> wrote:
> Is anyone using any of the USB-attached RAID backup systems? If so, can you
> share your recommendations and experienced. Connection would be to a PC that
> has two external USB2 drives as the main storage. I'd like to have some
> WindowsXP-compatible software that is crash-proof, doesn't hog resources and
> runs in the background, using idle times to keep things backed up to the
> attached RAID array. I've seen 2-HD and 4-HD enclosures, and I'm curious
> which kind other folks are using? I can't afford nor do I have the expertise
> to deal with one of the fancy NAS systems (plus, it would take forever to
> back up my studio drives over Ethernet, the backup needs to be via USB).
> Input much appreciated. Up to now, I've been manually backing up to a third,
> bigger USB drive. There's got to be a better way that won't take down
> Windows or be unreliable.
> BTW, for what it's worth, I signed up for Carbonite for my office PC last
> year. So far, 9 months into it, it's only got the PC and external hard drive
> 30% backed up! So, not a practical solution if you have a lot of data to
> backup! I don't run the PC 24-7, but I do leave it on overnight most nights.
> To Carbonite's credit, the software prioritized My Documents and the key
> system-identification files and those got backed up first. But stuff like my
> iTunes library, my extensive audio-documentaton library, my HDTracks
> downloads, it'll take literally years. Not practical!
> -- Tom Fine