Hi, Stewart. I'm not buying that heavy metal rap music requires less
fidelity. There is probably more actual high frequent content in such
music (a lot of it is electronic) than in a classical recording. As long
as recording studios are not recording to i-tune format (thank God we
haven't sunk to that level already), and recordings are issued in non-lossy
formats, they should be reviewed in the best format in which they are
issued, because that's how you can hear what they really sound like.
All this dumbing down is a terrible thing. And shameful for a so-called
music critic. I would agree with you if I-tunes is the only format in
which something is released.
Somebod,y somewhere really has to have some kind of standards about all
this. If a so-called, "self-identified" music critic admittedly has none,
he/she really ought to be doing something else for a living.
On Mon, Mar 30, 2015 at 11:31 AM, Frank Strauss <[log in to unmask]> wrote:
> Hi Tom-very interesting article. For me, sort of coincidental. I have
> about 400 GB of music on my HD. Most of it CD's downloaded at WAV
> resolution, some of it purchased online at 320, some of it purchased online
> in FLAC. I unfortunately saved some CD's in 192, back in the day. I have
> saved all the CD's. I have used iTunes as my player and music organizer,
> because it seems, to me, to be the best of a not stellar array of players.
> One of the issues I have with iTunes is that it doesn't like to supply
> album art for WAV or FLAC media. Not only doesn't it supply album art, but
> it won't let me put it in. Imagine my delight upon finding something
> called Tidymymusic from a Chinese company called Wondershare. Wondershare
> has been around quite a while, and the reviews for Tidymymusic were good.
> Supposedly Tidymymusic would go through my iTunes library and look for
> album art on line that was not present, then apply the album art. It would
> also "tidy up" the metadata. I started it running. It found 16,000 pieces
> of music, and told me it could automatically handle 12,400 of the pieces.
> I have the library backed up, so I let it run. After about 2,000 pieces
> had been processed, I noticed that the metadata in a significant number of
> selections had been changed to Japanese. Probably when Tidymymusic went on
> line there were some choices to be made, and it chose the Japanese one.
> This was a blessing in disguise, because now I am going through all the
> discs and correcting the Japanese data, and changing the 192's to WAV. I'm
> glad I saved the CD's.
> On Mon, Mar 30, 2015 at 10:21 AM, Tom Fine <[log in to unmask]>
> > http://www.nytimes.com/2015/03/29/opinion/sunday/what-
> > starbucks-is-ditching-along-with-cds.html
> > I still think the demise will be slow in genres like jazz and classical,
> > where buyers still want to read liner notes. However, I do think the day
> > will come in my lifetime when the compact disc is a submerged medium.
> > DVD/SACD/Bluray and all other 5" plastic shiny discs read by lasers. I
> > don't think they'll be fully submerged, they'll pop up here and there in
> > specialized applications and may well make a "comeback" among hipster
> > fans like the current cassette fad.
> > For what it's worth, I still buy CDs and I occasionally buy
> > high-resolution downloads. In the entire time since the launch of
> iTunes, I
> > have paid less than $100 all told for lossy downloads. They are a
> > last-ditch thing, I'll only buy them if I can't find the music in any
> > better-sounding format at a halfway reasonable price. I know, I'm a
> > antique!
> > -- Tom Fine
> Frank B Strauss, DMD