Not silly. Not silly at all!
His T4 is equally epic.
As to getting an orchestra, any orchestra, to play as from a recording
would require the enthusiastic cooperation of a conductor. Here in Boston
you might, just might, get Andriss Nelsons to go along with the idea. But
the Boston Symphony today, every orchestra, is a different beast, not so
used to unanimous rubato, portamento etc. But surely worth a try.
On Mon, Jun 6, 2016 at 2:12 PM, James Roth <[log in to unmask]> wrote:
> Hello everybody.
> The first time I ever heard the 5th of Tchaikovsky was on a recording of
> Koussevitzky and the BSO - a 45 RPM box set.
> That rendition has stuck with me (it's my favorite) and I've yet to hear
> anyone - even Bernstein - conduct with S.K.'s rubatos, creshendo's, etc.
> I wish there were. While S.K.'s rendition is my favorite by far, it's
> lacking in the clarity of later technology.
> The live ones are a little clearer than the 1946 studio recordings, but
> If I had the funds, I'd hire the BSO to study his recording and then play
> it back exactly that way.
> Is that silly?
> Ben Roth