So, it would seem that Tahra is mistaken when they claim that this CD contains his complete Pathe recordings.
From: Association for Recorded Sound Discussion List <[log in to unmask]> On Behalf Of Henri Chamoux
Sent: Wednesday, October 21, 2020 3:32 PM
To: [log in to unmask]
Subject: [EXTERNAL] Re: [ARSCLIST] Dating a Pathe disc
This message did not originate from SUNY Potsdam or one of its trusted senders. Do not open attachments, click on links, or provide your credentials if the source is suspicious.
Thanks Gary and Steve for your messages and feedback.
As regards Édouard Colonne recordings at Pathé : it is true there were cylinders of orchestra directed by Colonne on some 1901 Pathé catalogues. Yet I've got/seen three examples of these 1901 Colonne cylinders, all of the nice artistic series with a photo portrait of the artist on lid of green boxes. Alas, these three cylinders are as moldy as they can be, and probably inaudible.
One still can hope to find good copies of these cylinders someday...
with the idea that all of them are not doomed. Actually some other cylinders of the same artistic series (one vaudeville singer : Polin, a few opera/operetta singers such as Judic, Marignan, Fournets, Melchissedec, Soulacroix, Vaguet, or violinist Louis Planel) play beautifully when in good condition...
The Colonne 1906-1907 discs are actual takes done in 1906-1907, and clearly not transfers of these 1901 cylinders. To my knowledge these discs were not issued before 1919 or 1920, on paper label only. They are compiled on a CD
Only one audible on the Phonobase : Les ruines d'Athènes (Beethoven), recorded 1906-1907, transferred on paper label dated 22/01/1919 (crazy, yes ! Date is visible on tiny reverse handwritten digits around the label). http://www.phonobase.org/11146.html
With greetings from France
Le 20/10/2020 à 23:56, Steven Smolian a écrit :
> Hello, Mr. Chamoux,
> Thank you for your help to us all. In that vein, have you a date the Edouard Colonne cylinders/discs were recorded?
> Wikipedia says a first group were cylinders, listed in the Pathe catalog of October, 1901, none of which have survived, and the second in 1906 which were issued as discs. Yet I'm certain that I've seen a photo of a cylinder box with his name as performer- but don't ask where or when.
> Steve Smolian
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Association for Recorded Sound Discussion List
> [mailto:[log in to unmask]] On Behalf Of Henri Chamoux
> Sent: Tuesday, October 20, 2020 3:16 PM
> To: [log in to unmask]
> Subject: Re: [ARSCLIST] Dating a Pathe disc
> Greetings from France,
> Correct number for this Carmen flower song by Alvarez is 1644, not
> 1664 nor 1640.
> Visible (and audible) here : http://www.phonobase.org/8909.html
> Date is hard to know with precision. The disc was probably issued in
> 1907-1908, but it is the transfer of a 1903 or 1904 cylinder.
> And here a visible (and audible) example of the cylinder issue of 1664
> "Les boeufs" (Dupont) by the same Alvarez
> Best regards,
> Henri CHAMOUX
> http://www.archeophone.org : the many adventures of the archeophone
> http://www.phonobase.org : 10 000 morceaux de cire, de gomme-laque, de
> celluloïd à écouter en ligne http://phonobase.hypotheses.org :
> dernières nouvelles de la phonobase
> Le 20/10/2020 à 19:57, Gary A. Galo a écrit :
>> Hi Everyone,
>> I am trying to date a Pathe disc recording by Albert Alvarez, the Flower Song from Carmen. This recording was on an old LP produced by Henry Herrold in 1959, Herrold 5000, which also contained a bunch of Mapleson cylinders from Aida Favia-Artsay's collection. Aida gave a catalog number of 1664 for this record, but a recent reissue by Malibran says 1640. Malibran gives a date of 1905, but if 1640 is really the catalog number, a more likely date would seem to be 1903. I've checked various on-line references - DAHR, Kelly - without success, along with a private Alvarez CD sold on eBay, which gives 1640 as the catalog number and "1903 (?)" as the date.
>> 1664 is the catalog number of another recording, Les boeufs by Dupont, included on both the eBay CD and Malibran.
>> Can anyone shed any light on the correct date and catalog number for this record?
>> Gary Galo
>> Audio Engineer Emeritus
>> The Crane School of Music
>> SUNY at Potsdam, NY 13676
> Henri CHAMOUX
> http://www.archeophone.org : les aventures de l'archéophone, lauréat
> du cristal cnrs 2017 http://www.phonobase.org : 10 000 morceaux de
> cire, de gomme-laque, de celluloïd à écouter en ligne
> http://phonobase.hypotheses.org : dernières nouvelles de la phonobase
http://www.archeophone.org : les aventures de l'archéophone, lauréat du cristal cnrs 2017 http://www.phonobase.org : 10 000 morceaux de cire, de gomme-laque, de celluloïd à écouter en ligne http://phonobase.hypotheses.org : dernières nouvelles de la phonobase
École normale supérieure de Lyon
LARHRA - UMR 5190
Pôle histoire numérique
1 rue Maurice Arnoux
Tel : 06 64 80 00 81
[log in to unmask]