Print

Print


Dear Karen:

Rebecca and I have been working on example citation MODS records and
have a question for you.  Could you please tell us where you think the
date information should go in the following examples?

1.  Book Chapter:

This is a record with a related item that is a monograph.

Citation:
Amin, Ash. "Post-Fordism: Models, Fantasies and Phantoms of
Transition." In Post-Fordism: A Reader, edited by Ash Amin. Oxford:
Blackwell Publishers, 1994, pp23-45. -->
        <mods>
                <titleInfo>
                        <title>Post-Fordism</title>
                        <subTitle>Models, Fantasies and Phantoms of
Transition</subTitle>
                </titleInfo>
                <name type="personal">
                        <namePart type="given">Ash</namePart>
                        <namePart type="family">Amin</namePart>
                        <role>
                                <roleTerm type="text"
authority="marcrelator">author</roleTerm>
                        </role>
                </name>
                <typeOfResource>text</typeOfResource>
                <relatedItem type="host">
                        <titleInfo>
                                <title>Post-Fordism</title>
                                <subTitle>A Reader</subTitle>
                        </titleInfo>
                        <name type="personal">
                                <namePart type="given">Ash</namePart>
                                <namePart type="family">Amin</namePart>
                                <role>
                                        <roleTerm
type="text">editor</roleTerm>
                                </role>
                        </name>
                        <originInfo>
                                <dateIssued>1994</dateIssued>
                                <publisher>Blackwell
Publishers</publisher>
                                <place>
                                        <placeTerm
type="text">Oxford</placeTerm>
                                </place>
                        </originInfo>
                        <part>
                                <extent unit="page">
                                        <start>23</start>
                                        <end>45</end>
                                </extent>
                        </part>
                </relatedItem>
                <identifier type="citekey">Amin1994a</identifier>
        </mods>

Here the date is under <relatedItem>.  It could also go beneath <part>
or even in the main part of the record.  Where do you think it belongs?

This is a journal article:

Citation:
Brenner, Neil. "The Urban Question as a Scale Question: Reflections on
Henri Lefebre, Urban Theory and the Politics of Scale." International
Journal of Urban and Regional Research 24, no. 2 (2000): 361-378. -->
        <mods>
                <titleInfo>
                        <title>The Urban Question as a Scale
Question</title>
                        <subTitle>Reflections on Henri Lefebre, Urban
Theory and the Politics of Scale</subTitle>
                </titleInfo>
                <name type="personal">
                        <namePart type="given">Neil</namePart>
                        <namePart type="family">Brenner</namePart>
                        <role>
                                <roleTerm type="text">author</roleTerm>
                        </role>
                </name>
                <typeOfResource>text</typeOfResource>
                <relatedItem type="host">
                        <titleInfo>
                                <title>International Journal of Urban
and Regional Research</title>
                        </titleInfo>
                        <part>
                                <detail type="volume">
                                        <number>24</number>
                                </detail>
                                <detail type="issue">
                                        <number>2</number>
                                        <caption>no.</caption>
                                </detail>
                                <extent unit="page">
                                        <start>361</start>
                                        <end>378</end>
                                </extent>
                                <date>2000</date>
                        </part>
                </relatedItem>
                <identifier type="citekey">BrennerN2000a</identifier>
        </mods>

Here date is under <part>.  But it could also be placed under
<relatedItem>.  Where do you think it should go?

Here is another journal:

<mods>
                <titleInfo>
                        <title>A Test Article with Multiple
Authors</title>
                </titleInfo>
                <name type="personal">
                        <namePart type="given">John</namePart>
                        <namePart type="family">Doe</namePart>
                        <role>
                                <roleTerm type="text">author</roleTerm>
                        </role>
                </name>
                <name type="personal">
                        <namePart type="given">Jane</namePart>
                        <namePart type="family">Smith</namePart>
                        <role>
                                <roleTerm type="text">author</roleTerm>
                        </role>
                </name>
                <name type="personal">
                        <namePart type="given">Hugo</namePart>
                        <namePart type="family">Chavez</namePart>
                        <role>
                                <roleTerm type="text">author</roleTerm>
                        </role>
                </name>
                <name type="personal">
                        <namePart type="given">Steve</namePart>
                        <namePart type="family">Jones</namePart>
                        <role>
                                <roleTerm type="text">author</roleTerm>
                        </role>
                </name>
                <typeOfResource>text</typeOfResource>
                <relatedItem type="host">
                        <titleInfo>
                                <title>Journal of Marginal
Research</title>
                        </titleInfo>
                        <part>
                                <detail type="volume">
                                        <number>12</number>
                                        <caption>vol.</caption>
                                </detail>
                                <detail type="issue">
                                        <number>44</number>
                                        <caption>no.</caption>
                                </detail>
                                <extent unit="page">
                                        <start>361</start>
                                        <end>378</end>
                                </extent>
                                        <date>2002</date>
                        </part>
                </relatedItem>
                <identifier type="citekey">DoeJ2002a</identifier>
        </mods>

Does the date below under <part> or under <relatedItem>?

Where would the date go in this example?  Can we repeat it?

Citation:
Batson, C. Daniel. 1990. How social is the animal? The human capacity
for caring. American Pyschologist 45 (March): 336-46.

        <mods>
                <titleInfo>
                        <title>How social is the animal?</title>
                        <subTitle>The human capacity for
caring</subTitle>
                </titleInfo>
                <name type="personal">
                        <namePart type="family">Batson</namePart>
                        <namePart type="given">C. Daniel</namePart>
                        <role>
                                <roleTerm type="text">author</roleTerm>
                        </role>
                </name>
                <originInfo>
                                <issuance>continuing</issuance>
                        </originInfo>
                <typeOfResource>text</typeOfResource>
                <relatedItem type="host">
                        <titleInfo>
                                <title>American Pyschologist</title>
                        </titleInfo>
                        <originInfo>
                                <dateIssued>March 1990</dateIssued>
                        </originInfo>
                        <genre>academic journal</genre>
                        <part>
                                <detail type="volume">
                                        <number>45</number>
                                </detail>
                                <date>March</date>
                                <extent unit="page">
                                        <start>336</start>
                                        <end>346</end>
                                </extent>
                                <date>March 1990</date>
                        </part>
                </relatedItem>
        </mods>


Thank you very much for your help, Karen!


Best wishes,

Jackie Radebaugh