Hi Tracy,

I work with MODS in Islandora*, and we are currently straining to figure
out how to deal with MODS in the future.

The Islandora community has been hugely invested in MODS (though badly
represented on your implementation list, I'm sorry to see) but with the
move to Fedora 4 and an RDF-based repository system, we have been
considering how best to deal with our data. I have been heading the
Metadata Interest Group for the last half-year with this goal in mind.

Do we try to express MODS in RDF?
Do we migrate to another expressive RDF-based schema, like BIBFRAME?
Do we abandon the granularity and expressiveness of MODS and condense into
Dublin Core Terms?
Do we retain MODS (and its underlying assumptions of an integral "metadata
record") and map dynamically into RDF where required?

We have been examining the two LOC initiatives, MODS RDF
<>,  and BIBFRAME
<>, with some trepidation. Both seem to make
excessive use of blank nodes, and are therefore hard to implement in the
way we had imagined (what does a BIBFRAME "record" editor look like?). MODS
RDF seems to be abandoned, and BIBFRAME doesn't have any conversions that
we can see from MODS, just MARC.

Would you have time to chat, about what LOC considers to be the future of
MODS, especially with relation to RDF?

Many thanks,


* The Islandora system includes a fantastic yet complicated system ("XML
Form Builder") which lets us create Drupal forms that map to MODS with
arbitrary complexity and XML attributes. Editing a MODS record using one of
these forms does so non-destructively (preserving any elements in the
original that aren't represented in the form). However this piece of
software is considered too complex to manage, and we do not see a
possibility to migrate it to the next version of Islandora.

On 8 January 2018 at 11:28, Meehleib, Tracy <[log in to unmask]> wrote:

> Hi MODS Users,
> We are in the process of updating the MODS Implementation Registry and
> Tools for MODS pages and would like to add any new projects/tools that are
> currently available to the community.
> If you would like your projects/tools to be included, please supply
> information for each category in the MODS Implementation Registry
> and/or Tools for MODS page
> mods/tools_for_mods.php, and we will add your projects/tools to the
> registry.
> If you have already registered an implementation or a tool, please take a
> moment to review the entry for it and send us any new information we might
> need to bring the entry up to date.
> Thank you, Tracy
> Tracy Meehleib
> Network Development and MARC Standards Office
> Library of Congress
> 101 Independence Ave SE
> Washington, DC 20540-4402
> +1 202 707 0121 (voice)
> +1 202 707 0115 (fax)
> [log in to unmask]


*Rosie Le Faive*

Digital Infrastructure and Discovery Librarian
tel: 902-566-0533 | fax: 902-628-4305 | email: [log in to unmask]

Robertson Library

University of Prince Edward Island

550 University Ave, Charlottetown PE C1A 4P3

Canada | @UPEILibrary <> |
instagram <>