Hello ARSC Group:

I have been a faithful member of ARSC for quite a few years now. 
Although this questions is not exactly focused on the preservation of 
recorded sound content, I hoping that someone on this list can provide 
some advice/input for a more personal inquiry, as I know there are quite 
a few people on this list-serve who have some copyright 

I am a member of a smaller Roman Catholic church in Upstate New York. 
About a year ago, I began web streaming a live camera broadcasting 24/7 
on YouTube for our church. For an entire year, there were no issues. 
Before we lost our YouTube account, we had over 900 unique instances 
each month where someone logged in to watch a regular church service, a 
funeral or a wedding. Then suddenly two months ago, YouTube sent me a 
notification that "due to multiple violations, your YouTube account was 
closed". There was no specific information as to why. I filed an appeal 
with no reply and we lost the account.

My best guess is that sometimes our parish priest will play store-bought 
religious CD's for background music before mass, during confessions to 
hide any extraneous conversions, etc. and the music went through the 
sound system and through our streaming hardware which was then broadcast 
through the YouTube live stream and YouTube picked up on the copyrighted 
music and punted us for copyright violations.

After doing a mass amount of research to find a qualified paid streaming 
service provider, I found more and more references pointing to the fact 
that if you broadcast your church services outside the four walls of 
your church, such as streaming your services, you need to purchase a 
rights license to be able to use the standard Roman Catholic church 
hymns in your streaming content. But these references conflict with 
other references that say we don't have to pay for a rights license. 
Some license companies ask that you report weekly a list of all the 
hymns sung in the services for the entire week. Some license companies 
state that you just pay a fixed fee to cover the church services for the 
entire year with no reporting. The streaming providers all say the same 
thing - no one is going to go through the time and trouble of suing a 
small catholic church for streaming hymns sung during a regular worship 
service - there's no money in it. There is no definitive answer for 
rights licensing protocol that I can find anywhere. It seems as the 
licensing companies are there to cash in on churches that are willing to 
pay to protect themselves. Our Diocese has not been able to provide any 
definitive answer either. There are not many churches in our diocese 
that do what we do. Apparently, streaming the Roman Catholic mass is not 
something many churches do in our area.

So my question is this....  Does anyone on this list have some 
experience or practical experience in this area? If we only stick to 
streaming broadcast of hymns sung during live Roman Catholic Church 
services (and we do not play any other pre-recorded music before during 
or after services) are we within our rights to broadcast the services 
through web streaming without having to pay for additional copyright 
protection? If not and we should purchase a rights license, does anyone 
have recommendations for a rights license service provider where the 
service is reputable, the costs are reasonable and the reporting isn't 
to a point that it requires a lot of weekly work?

Thanks in advance for any input.

Kind Regards,

John Schroth

Media Transfer Service, LLC
High Quality Conversion Of:
Video - Audio - Motion Picture - Still Image
Phone: 585-248-4908
Find out what's new at MTS: