I second Michelle’s frustration and suggestion.
Technical Services Manager
7851 Timber Drive, Tinley Park, IL 60477
708.845.5713 | tplibrary.org
These types of records drive me crazy! Often I would like to use a subject heading like Lawyers--Fiction, but the authority record causes it to flip to Legal stories (which is not necessarily appropriate for the work I'm cataloging). Now that we have LCGFT, I wonder if it should be proposed to have these 450s removed. Then we could use Lawyers--Fiction, Christmas--Fiction, or Hunting--Fiction if we want to, and additionally apply the LCGFT term when appropriate.
Special Collections Cataloger
Special Collections Technical Services
CB#3926, Wilson Library
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
From: Program for Cooperative Cataloging <[log in to unmask]> on behalf of Wilson, Pete <[log in to unmask]>
Sent: Wednesday, June 24, 2020 2:49 PM
To: [log in to unmask] <[log in to unmask]>
Subject: [PCCLIST] "Christmas stories" and similar subject headings
There are certain LCSH headings like “Christmas stories” and “Hunting stories” which have long worried me a bit.
These headings have the cross references “Christmas – Fiction” and “Hunting – Fiction.” If you want to use a subject heading to say that a work is fiction about Christmas, you’re led through the cross reference to the 150 “Christmas stories.” That’s used instead of the topic + form combination “Christmas – Fiction.”
Yet “Christmas stories” looks very like a form/genre heading. And there’s already a perfectly good LCGFT heading, “Christmas fiction.” So do you abandon your 650, instead using only a 655, “Christmas fiction?”
My guess is no. Why should we not have a 650 to say that what we’re cataloging is about Christmas? We routinely give topical headings, subdivided by form, to works of fiction, and “Christmas stories” is the authority-mandated substitute here for the topical heading “Christmas” subdivided by form “fiction.” I’m thinking that “Christmas stories” is perfectly acceptable as a 650 for a novel about Christmas. (Not just for a collection of Christmas stories. The novel would get the heading “Christmas – Fiction” were that not unacceptable, so it gets “Christmas stories.”)
Does this sound correct?